A study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences has found that losing just one hour of sleep to the spring daylight saving time change was associated with a measurable increase in how often employees clicked on simulated phishing emails, offering a real-world window into how even mild sleep loss affects everyday decision-making.
A Natural Experiment at Work
Rather than running a controlled sleep-deprivation experiment, researchers led by Eitan Schechtman, an assistant professor of neurobiology and behavior at UC Irvine, took advantage of an existing cybersecurity awareness program at a large, unnamed U.S. employer. The company's IT department routinely sends employees fake phishing emails designed to mimic real malicious attempts, then tracks who clicks the embedded links, as a way of measuring and reinforcing security awareness.
The researchers compared click rates among more than 11,000 employees during the Monday before the spring clock change — when most people lose about an hour of sleep adjusting to the new schedule — against the Monday after it.
What the Data Showed
Phishing-link click rates rose from about 15.56% before the time change to 17.76% afterward, roughly a 13 to 14% relative increase in the odds that an employee would click a simulated malicious link. The researchers frame this as evidence that even a modest, society-wide sleep disruption — far milder than acute sleep deprivation studied in a lab — can measurably shift real-world risk-taking and vigilance.
The study, titled "Modest loss of sleep increases susceptibility to cybersecurity threats" (PNAS, DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2622467123), is notable for using an existing corporate dataset rather than a lab-based design, which lets the researchers observe behavior at a scale — and under real stakes — that a traditional sleep lab study couldn't easily replicate.
Why This Matters Beyond Email
Phishing emails are one of the most common ways cyberattacks succeed, and organizations spend heavily on training employees to spot them. This study suggests that timing may matter as much as training: a workforce that is collectively sleep-deprived, even mildly and for a predictable reason like a clock change, may be measurably more vulnerable regardless of how well-trained it is.
Schechtman has suggested the effect likely isn't limited to clicking email links. The kind of fatigue-driven lapse in vigilance seen here plausibly extends to other daily decisions that rely on sustained attention and skepticism — from financial choices to safety-critical judgments — though the study itself only directly measured phishing susceptibility.
What This Means for Patients
This research is a reminder that the consequences of insufficient sleep aren't limited to mood, memory, or cardiovascular health — they extend into everyday judgment and risk assessment in ways most people don't consciously notice. A single hour of lost sleep is a small disruption compared to chronic insomnia or sleep apnea, yet it still produced a detectable, population-level shift in vulnerability to deception.
For individuals, the practical takeaway is to be extra cautious about unsolicited emails and links in the days immediately following a sleep-disrupting event, including time changes, travel across time zones, or a stretch of poor sleep. For employers and security teams, the findings suggest that phishing-awareness campaigns and system safeguards might be especially valuable to reinforce around predictable sleep-loss events like the twice-yearly clock change, rather than treating vigilance as constant across the calendar.